| MLB | 99 Award Chipper Jones | 99 Prime Mickey Mantle | 99 Signature Willie Mays |
| AL | 99 Signature David Ortiz | 99 Signature Craig Biggio | 99 Signature Ivan Rodriguez |
| NL | 99 Milestone Alphonso Soriano | 99 Award Gary Sheffield | 99 Signature Rogers Hornsby |
| ALE | 95 All Star Rich Gossage | 91 All Star Roberto Alomar | 92 All Star Jose Bautista |
| ALC | 95 Postseason Rickey Henderson | 90 Rookie Walter Johnson | 90 Hardware Harmon Killebrew |
| ALW | 93 All Star Bob Feller | 94 All Star Billy Wagner | 93 Hardware Vida Blue |
| NLE | 96 Milestone Tom Glavine | 92 Breakout Mike Schmidt | 93 Breakout Eddie Mathews |
| NLC | 94 Breakout Ernie Banks | 90 Postseason Willie Stargell | 90 Veteran Jim Edmonds |
| NLW | 96 Milestone Steve Finley | 93 All Star Tony Gwynn | 92 Veteran Robb Nen |
| BAL | 83 Veteran Jim Palmer | 80 All Star Mark Trumbo | 82 Breakout Jonathon Schoop |
| BOS | 87 Veteran Lefty Grove | 86 Veteran Shane Victorino | 90 All Star Jacoby Ellsbury |
| NYY | 90 2nd Half Jorge Posada | 92 All Star Jason Giambi | 90 All Star Robinson Cano |
| TB | 86 All Star David Price | 85 All Star Evan Longoria | 84 Veteran Fred McGriff |
| TOR | 87 Postseason Joe Carter | 84 Veteran A.J. Burnett | 84 Veteran Brett Cecil |
| CWS | 89 All Star Paul Konerko | 82 Breakout Mark Buehrle | 82 All Star Avisail Garcia |
| CLE | 85 All Star Cliff Lee | 88 Postseason Cody Allen | 91 All Star Kenny Lofton |
| DET | 84 Veteran Ivan Rodriguez | 81 Breakout Jack Morris | 83 Breakout Alan Trammell |
| KC | 84 Breakout George Brett | 81 Veteran Mike Minor | 83 All Star Kelvin Herrera |
| MIN | 89 Postseason Kirby Puckett | 86 Veteran Torii Hunter | 83 Breakout Rod Carew |
| LAA | 95 Prime Frank Tanana | 85 All Star Garret Anderson | 85 All Star Troy Percival |
| OAK | 87 Postseason Dennis Eckersley | 88 All Star Sean Doolittle | 82 All Star Rollie Fingers |
| SEA | 84 Rookie Michael Pineda | 81 Veteran Robinson Cano | 83 Rookie Carson Smith |
| TEX | 84 Veteran Bert Blyleven | 84 All Star Michael Young | 80 Veteran Derek Holland |
| HOU | 89 Veteran Jeff Bagwell | 92 All Star Nolan Ryan | 91 Hardware Mike Scott |
| ATL | 91 All Star Andruw Jones | 87 Postseason Ryan Klesko | 89 All Star Warren Spahn |
| MIA | 84 All Star Dee Gordon | 81 Breakout Al Leiter | 81 Rookie Kyle Barraclough |
| NYM | 91 Milestone John Franco | 89 Veteran John Olerud | 88 All Star Mike Piazza |
| PHI | 87 Veteran Roy Oswalt | 86 Breakout Robin Roberts | 87 All Star Cole Hamels |
| WAS | 86 2nd Half Ryan Zimmerman | 91 Breakout Vladimir Guerrero | 86 All Star Daniel Murphy |
| CHC | 85 All Star Kerry Wood | 86 Rookie Mark Prior | 87 Hardware Ryne Sandberg |
| CIN | 83 Rookie Adam Dunn | 85 Breakout George Foster | 87 All Star Dave Parker |
| MIL | 88 Veteran Robin Yount | 87 All Star Dan Plesac | 85 All Star Jonathan Lucroy |
| PIT | 81 All Star Ralph Kiner | 83 Rookie Andrew McCutchen | 82 Breakout Willie Stargell |
| STL | 92 All Star Stan Musial | 85 Veteran Jason Isringhausen | 87 Hardware Albert Pujols |
| ARI | 80 Breakout Archie Bradley | 87 Breakout Luis Gonzalez | 80 Breakout Mark Reynolds |
| COL | 89 Rookie Todd Helton | 85 Veteran Adam Ottavino | 86 Postseason Carlos Gonzalez |
| LAD | 92 Breakout Eric Gagne | 92 Rookie Mike Piazza | 92 Postseason Orel Hershiser |
| SD | 90 2nd Half Trevor Hoffman | 87 Breakout Steve Finley | 88 All Star Adrian Gonzalez |
| SF | 82 Rookie Hunter Strickland | 83 Breakout Matt Williams | 83 Hardware Orlando Cepeda |
